The Swiss voted on Sunday to tighten their notoriously lax tobacco laws by banning virtually all advertising of the hazardous products, with nearly 57 percent of voters and 16 of Switzerland’s 26 cantons backing the near-total ban, final results showed.
“We are extremely happy. The people understood that health is more important than economic interests, ”Stefanie De Borba of the Swiss League against Cancer told AFP news agency.
Switzerland lags far behind most wealthy nations in restricting tobacco advertising – a situation widely blamed on substantial lobbying by some of the world’s biggest tobacco companies with headquarters in the country.
Currently, most tobacco advertising is legal at a national level, except on television and radio, and when specifically targeting minors.
Some Swiss cantons have introduced stricter regional legislation and a new national law is pending, but the campaigners who forced the issue to a vote under Switzerland’s direct democracy system demanded far tighter rules.
Opponents of the initiative, which include the Swiss government and parliament, argued that it goes too far.
Politically correct ‘dictatorship’
“Today we are talking about cigarettes, but we will soon be talking about alcohol and meat,” warned Philippe Bauer, a parliamentarian with the right-wing Liberal Party, decrying “this dictatorship of the politically correct, where everything has to be regulated” .
His concerns echo those voiced by Philip Morris International (PMI), the world’s largest tobacco company, which, like British American Tobacco and Japan Tobacco, has headquarters in Switzerland and has helped fund the “No” campaign.
“This is a slippery slope as far as individual freedom is concerned,” a spokesman for PMI’s Swiss section told AFP.
He decried Sunday’s result and urged parliament to show “moderation and measure” when drafting the decision into law.
Jean-Paul Humair, who heads a Geneva addiction prevention center, hailed Sunday’s win as “a very important step” in the battle against tobacco use, and flatly rejected the industry’s arguments.
“This is not a question of freedom. It is an illusion of freedom,” he told AFP, pointing out that tobacco use creates severe dependency.
‘Kills half of all users’
“There is no other consumer product that kills half of all users.”
Campaigners say lax advertising laws have stymied efforts to bring down smoking rates in the Alpine nation of 8.6 million people, where more than a quarter of adults consume tobacco products. There are about 9,500 tobacco-linked deaths each year.
Opponents of the initiative, which include the Swiss government and parliament, argued that it goes too far [Valentin Flauraud/AFP]Pascal Diethelm, head of the OxyRomandie tobacco control group, told AFP that Sunday’s vote should help lead to a “change of paradigm” for federal authorities.
“(They) have been accepting for too long that health prevention policies be put under the tutelage of big business,” they said.
The tobacco industry contributes about six billion Swiss francs ($ 6.5 billion) to the economy annually – one percent of Switzerland’s gross domestic product – and accounts for some 11,500 jobs.
Swiss health minister Alain Berset meanwhile stressed to journalists that it could take time for the near-ban to take effect.
“It really does not seem possible that it could take effect this year,” he said.
The new tobacco advertising restrictions could conceivably be added to a new tobacco law already due to take effect next year, and which for the first time will set a nationwide minimum age for the purchase of tobacco products.
Animal testing
Other issues on Sunday’s ballot did not fare as well in the polls.
Nearly 80 percent of voters rejected a call to ban all animal testing.
All political parties, parliament and the government had opposed the initiative, arguing it went too far and would have dire consequences for medical research.
In another animal-themed vote, residents in the northern Basel-Stadt canton also hugely rejected a bid to afford non-human primates some of the same basic fundamental rights as their human cousins, with nearly 75 percent opposed.
More than 55 percent of voters also rejected a plan by the national government to provide additional state funding to media companies, which have seen their advertising revenues evaporate in recent years.
Nearly 44 percent of eligible Swiss voters took part on Sunday, which is not unusually low in a country where such popular votes are held every few months.
